|
Kerner Commission Report Forty Years
After
Eisenhower Foundation Updates
Fred Harris Interviewed by Bill
Moyers on the
Kerner Commission
Bill Moyers: In March of
1968, the Report was published. It was brutal in its
honesty:
While saying that a growing black
militancy may have added fuel to the riots, the
commission rejected the idea that there'd been any
organization behind the outbreaks. Instead, the Commission blamed the
violence on the devastating poverty and hopelessness
endemic in the inner cities of the 1960s.
Among their many findings:
|
One in five
African-Americans lived in "squalor and
deprivation in ghetto neighborhoods."
The unemployment rate
was double for African-Americans, as
compared to whites.
The report described
communities that were neglected by their
government, wracked with crime, and
traumatized by police brutality.
Disproportionate rates
of infant mortality were astonishing -
African-American children dying at triple
the rate of white children. |
The statistics weren't new. But the
Kerner Commission pushed further, and laid the blame for
many of these conditions on white racism: quote "what
white Americans have never fully understood—but what
the Negro can never forget—is that the white society
is deeply implicated in the ghetto. White institutions
created it. White institutions maintain it, and white
society condones it."
The report's conclusion—and it's
most memorable message—was this: "our nation is moving
towards two societies - one white, one black - separate
and unequal."
Fred Harris: We used the
word racism. And on the commission, we had two or three
people say, "Should we use that word, racism?"
Bill Moyers: Not a word that
was thrown around largely by—government panels in the
1960s.
Fred Harris: We felt that
was very important. I did and I think it was to say it.
Because what we know is that oppressed people often come
to believe about themselves the same bad stereotypes
that the dominant society has. Our saying racism—think was very important to a lot of black people who
said, "Well, maybe it's not just me. Maybe I'm not—by
myself at fault here. Maybe there's something else going
on."
Bill Moyers: I remember that
the headlines based on the premature leak of a summary
of the report would read—"A Commission Blames Riots on
Whites."
Fred Harris: That's right.
Bill Moyers: White racism.
And that inflamed—whites who didn't want to be blamed.
Fred Harris: No,
that's right. But we felt—now I think if we had time to
background it so that people would have understood it a
little better. What we telling about—with racism was
not—one white person hating one black—or all black
people. We're talking about kind of an institutional
racism which existed. And where people live in all white
neighborhoods. Send their kids to all white schools.
Drive quickly through black section maybe, or on the
train, to a job where all their associates are white.
And don't see anything odd about it. That was what—
Bill Moyers: The natural
order of things.
Fred Harris: That's
right. That's what we were talking about. . . .
* *
* * *
Bill Moyers: Looking back
all this time, what did the Kerner Commission get right?
Fred Harris:
I think well virtually everything was right. And I could
add onto that this. I think one of the awfulest thing's
that came out of the Reagan presidency and later was the
feeling that government can't do anything right. And
that—everything it does is wrong. The truth is that
virtually everything we tried worked. We just quit
trying it. Or we didn't try it hard enough. And that's
what we need to get back to. We made progress on
virtually every aspect of race and poverty—for about a
decade after the Kerner Commission Report. And then,
particularly with the advent of the Reagan
Administration, and so forth, that progress stopped. And
we began to go backwards. There are consequences from
our acts, and when we—cut out a lot of these—social
programs, or the money for them, or cut it down—we don't
emphasize jobs and training, and education, and so forth
as we had been doing, there are bad consequences from
that.
Bill Moyers:
The Reagan conservatives were quite critical of the
Kerner Commission as being unbalanced and simplistic.
They say, for example, that you failed to take into
consideration that the close correlation between being
born out of wedlock, and growing up without a father,
and being poor, that your work over the years actually
exempts the poor from being responsible for their own
condition.
Fred Harris:
Well, you know, the breakdown in families is just like
sort of crime and narcotics and so forth. These are the
consequences. They're the handmaidens in the sense
of-poverty . . . I said at the time, there
are a lot of people who want to—punish
people for being poor. You know, say, "It's your own
fault." We want to punish people for being poor. I said,
"I I used to poor myself. And being poor is punishment
enough." I think what you need to do is to help
people—up, give 'em a hand up. And recognize the kind of
terrible conditions that they're grown up in.
Bill Moyers:
For the last thirty years, Fred Harris has been teaching
politics at the University of New Mexico. . . .But he
never lost his commitment to the cause of the Kerner
Commission. When he's not in the classroom, he's part of
major, ongoing investigation into the issues of race and
poverty today.
Harris sits on the
board of the Eisenhower Foundation based in Washington
D.C. the Foundation was created to continue the Kerner
Commission. Its work is to research and support
successful programs in the inner cities.
* *
* * *
Eisenhower
Foundation Reports
Every few years,
Eisenhower publishes an updated set of findings: a
report card of how the country is dealing with the key
issues raised by Kerner. Alan Curtis is President of the
Eisenhower Foundation.
Alan Curtis: The
Kerner Commission said, "Look. These problems can be
solved. Let's not give up hope. And so, we try to be
keepers of the flame of that message. That there is
hope. There are solutions. And we remind America every
so often, that we still have a long ways to go in
fulfilling the prophesies of those commissions and their
recommendations.
Bill Moyers:
Alan Curtis and Fred Harris have been holding hearings
in Washington, Detroit and Newark to prepare a report on
the 40th anniversary of Kerner.
Alan Curtis:
We want to listen. We're taking testimony. We would
encourage you to discuss today not only the solutions,
but how to change political will in America so that we
can embrace the priorities of the Kerner Commission and
we can begin to fulfill America's promise.
* *
* * *
A Striking Set of Voices
Komozi Woodard:
We've gone from an urban crisis in the '60s to an
urban catastrophe in the 21st Century. That's what
you're looking at when you look at Katrina. That's what
you're looking at when you look at gentrification. We
are in an urban catastrophe community, we need to be
blunt about it because if we use the wrong words, it
doesn't wake people up, It puts them to sleep. This is
not an ordinary situation and it is a national
situation. It is not a Newark situation.
Junius Williams:
Big northeastern cities are home to some of the most
concentrated poverty in the country, and that's your new
split. That's your new division.
Ronald Anglin:
We're seeing lives of quiet desperation that we have
cordoned off communities in which we allow crime to
exist. We allow lots of bad things to exist, and as long
as they don't spill over, that's okay.
Richard
Cammareri: I would take issue with one of the
premises of the most famous quote in this that we're
moving towards two societies. I would respectfully
suggest that we never were one society in this country.
This country has simply never confronted the issue of
race. . Race is, I guess to use a religious term, the
original sin of this country.
Heaster Wheeler:
I believe 40 years later, today the conditions here in
Southeast Michigan are just as ripe for protest, and
demonstration, and possibly all those other negative
things as they were 40 years later. You need not look
too far to see Jena, Louisiana and all of the other
challenges.
Maureen Taylor:
On my way here, there are people on corners, standing up
with signs, say, "Will work for food." But we're in
here, talking about what's the problem?
Josephine Huyghe:
You want to know what's going on? It's somebody say,
"It's the same old, same old." With the continuation of
white flight that started in the '50s has been
compounded by the exodus of the middle and upper class
blacks as Detroit experienced a 'brain drain'.
Dr. Herbert
Smitherman: In 1970, the infant mortality rate, that
is our babies dying before age of one, was about 65
percent higher in the black community than in the white
community. Currently, it's 205 percent higher in the
black community than in the white community.
George Galster:
The City of Detroit constitutes 85 percent black
residents, only nine percent white residents. The
poverty rate—white, it's only 5.9 percent, blacks: 24
percent. The median family income—for whites, over
$65,000, for blacks, only $37,000. We could go on and
on, but, it's very clear that there are these measurable
distinctions between blacks and whites in metro Detroit.
Rev. Kevin
Turman: The young people of my congregation and my
community are as industrious as you will find anywhere.
They are as innovative and as intelligent as any that
you will find anywhere. But unfortunately, they have a
number of challenges that have been un-addressed,
because the recommendations of the Kerner Commission
were ignored or dismissed.
Roy Levy
Williams: The one industry which has flourished is
the prison industry. And, yes, it has become an
industry. During the last 15 years, this state has been
averaging one brand new prison a year
Glenda McGadney:
We have got to get serious about what's going on and
what our government is allowing to happen to us, and how
we're losing our rights every single day. And all this
money that's being spent for the war, we need to pray
about that. Because it should not be going to Iraq. It
should be right here in our cities, in our neighborhood.
Dr. Herbert
Smitherman: When we had 9/11, we were arguing about
Social Security reform. Where are we gonna find the
money for it? And within 48 hours after 9/11, we found
$40 billion for New York City, a billion dollars an
hour. When we want to do something as a country, we do
it. This is not about can we do. This is about a will.
This is about do we want to do. When you start saying
I'm gonna have cuts in Medicare and Medicaid, cuts to
housing in urban development, no subsidies to mass
transit, eliminate funding for job training, cut school
lunch programs for inner city children, eliminate school
loan programs for minority students, repeal after-school
programs. What I'm saying is this is about public
policy. This is about resource implementation.
Karl Gregory: The 1968
Kerner Commission conclusion that racism is deeply
embedded in the American society is still true. Racism
is still as American as apple pie in this area. The
existing huge disparities by race could not exist
without racism.
* *
* * *
Eisenhower Foundation Reports
Bill Moyers:
The Eisenhower Foundation has now issued their
preliminary report and it echoed the testimony they
heard across the country:
While noting that
certain things have improved - such as the dramatic
growth of the black middle class—the foundation
nonetheless concludes that "America has, for the most
part, failed to meet the Kerner Commission's goals of
less poverty, inequality, racial injustice and crime."
Among the troubling facts:
|
Thirty
seven million Americans live in poverty
today. But African-Americans are three times
as likely to be at the very bottom of the
scale, living in what's known as 'deep
poverty'
Median non-white
families have just one-fifth the wealth of
white families
And…over the last 20
years, three times as many African-American
men go to prison as go to college |
Alan Curtis:
Many people today—Americans have short memories, of
course—don't realize, for example, that the sentence for
a minority person is longer than a sentence for a white
person going to prison. Minorities are more likely to
get the death sentence than white. The sentences for
crack cocaine, used disproportionately by minorities,
are longer than the sentences for powdered cocaine, used
disproportionately by whites. And so, there is still
this endemic, institutional racism in America that
people forget about. And I think they need to be
reminded about that.
Bill Moyers: The Eisenhower
Foundation's full report will be released later this
year.
* *
* * *
Fred Harris
Interviewed by Bill Moyers on the Kerner Commission
Bill Moyers:
Fred, you've been teaching democracy down there at the
University of New Mexico for 30 years. Your textbook on
democracy is used in universities all over the country.
Why can't democracy deal with these persistent, chronic
realities that the Kerner Commission described and you
here 40 years later are restating?
Fred Harris
: Well I think first of all—people don't really realize
that conditions are so bad for so many people in poverty
and—and for African-Americans, and for Hispanics. I
think a lot of people say, well, didn't we do all that?
And I think if people knew these conditions and that's
what we ought to do on the 40th anniversary of the
Kerner Report is to get people to see that these
problems of race and poverty are still with us. Also, I
think we need to approach this on a basis of that we're
all in this together. Somebody said we may not have all
come over on the same boat but we're all in the same
boat now.
And here's the
interesting thing. Every poll that's taken shows that
two-thirds of Americans think America's on the wrong
footing. They're headed in the wrong direction. And
there's overwhelming support for example this: do you
think we ought to spend more on-- in prevention-- by
putting money in education and training and jobs,
instead of police and prisons. Overwhelmingly people
say, yes. Do you think that we ought to have a social
net—so—just to catch people falling out and to give them
another chance? Oh, yes, they strongly believe in that.
What about healthcare? We got 46 million people without
health insurance. And yet overwhelmingly Americans say,
yes, I think we ought to have—healthcare even
if—everybody—universal healthcare even if it costs us
more money. So the public is way ahead of the
politicians I think.
And I just think that, as I said,
it's in our own interests, and everybody's interests to
try to do something about it. We can do it.
Source:
PBS—Bill
Moyers
* *
* * *
February 29, 1968
Kerner Commission Report
released
The President's
National Advisory Commission on Civil Disorders releases
its report, condemning racism as the primary cause of
the recent surge of riots. The report, which declared
that "our nation is moving toward two societies, one
black, one white—separate and unequal," called for
expanded aid to African American communities in order to
prevent further racial violence and polarization. Unless
drastic and costly remedies were undertaken at once, the
report said, there would be a "continuing polarization
of the American community and, ultimately, the
destruction of basic democratic values."
The report
identified more than 150 riots or major disorders
between 1965 and 1968 and blamed "white racism" for
sparking the violence—not a conspiracy by African
American political groups as some claimed. Statistics
for 1967 alone included 83 people killed and 1,800
injured—the majority of them African Americans--and
property valued at more than $100 million damaged or
destroyed. The 11-member commission, headed by Governor
Otto Kerner of Illinois, was appointed by President
Lyndon B. Johnson in July 1967 to uncover the causes of
urban riots and recommend solutions.
History.com
* * *
* *
40 years later,
racial gap hasn't quite disappeared—Last week, the
Pew Center on the States issued a report that finds the
U.S. leads the world in incarceration rates and raw
numbers, especially for young black men. More than one
in 100 adults in the U.S. is in jail or prison, the
report said. That includes one in every nine black men
ages 20 to 34. Throwing more offenders in prison reduces
crime, studies show, but so does reducing joblessness,
raising wages and putting more police officers on the
streets, according to Adam Gelb, who co-authored the Pew
report.America's low-income neighborhoods and their
school systems are still segregated by race, but with a
key difference from 1968: Today's racial divide is a
consequence of an income divide. White flight to the
suburbs in the wake of the riots in the 1960s was
quickly followed by middle-class black flight. Today's
urban poor are fewer in number but more isolated, not
only from the white mainstream but also from upwardly
mobile blacks. Instead of traditional street riots, a
group of experts who included former Kerner Commission
members said in a follow-up report 20 years ago, we have
"quiet riots" of street crimes, drug addiction, family
violence and other self-destructive behavior stirred by
rage, frustration and despair. Ten years from now, as we
look at the 50th anniversary of the Kerner report, I
hope we can point to progress in closing the gap between
the upwardly mobile and those stuck on the bottom. A
presidential campaign is an excellent time to begin that
task. We don't need to wait for a riot.
Baltimore Sun
* * *
* *
Forty Year Update of the Kerner Riot
Commission
By The Eisenhower
Foundation (February 2008)
Executive
Summary
The bipartisan National
Advisory Commission on Civil Disorders issued its final
report to the nation on March 1, 1968. Convened by
President Lyndon B. Johnson, the panel was known as the
Kerner Commission, after then-Illinois Governor Otto
Kerner.
The Eisenhower Foundation is
the private sector continuation of the Kerner Commission
and the bipartisan Eisenhower Violence Commission. The
latter was formed by President Johnson and extended by
President Nixon.
The Foundation periodically
updates the Kerner and Violence commissions. For this 40
year Kerner update, we have held hearings in Detroit,
Newark and Washington DC – to secure recommendations
from citizens, the media, religious leaders, public
sector officials, private sector leaders and others.
(See eisenhowerfoundation.org for hearing transcripts
and video testimony.)
The 40 year findings
summarized here also draw on papers and advice from the
Foundation’s Fortieth Anniversary Task Force of 40
experts and scholars. (See Attachment 3.)
We intend to dialogue with the
American people on the preliminary findings in
thepresent report and then revise it into a final report
to be published late in 2008. What follows, then, is the
beginning of an inclusionary process.
What Did the Kerner Commission
Conclude?
The Kerner Commission
responded to the wave of disorders around the nation
from 1963 to 1967. They were called “riots” in the
mainstream media, but often were called “rebellions” in
the communities where they took place. The frequency of
such violent group conflict diminished in later years –
with a few notable exceptions, like the 1984 Liberty
City disorders in Miami and the 1992 disorders in South
Central Los Angeles after the first Rodney King trial
verdict.
In terms of long run policy
outcomes, the Kerner Commission in large part focused on
how to reduce poverty, inequality, racial injustice and
crime. (In some ways, individual acts of crime and
violence are “quiet riots” – safer from police detection
than large scale group disturbances.) The Commission
concluded that “important segments of the media failed
to report adequately on the causes of civil disorders
and on the underlying problems of race relations….”
American media emphasized the
Commission’s characterization of two societies, Black
and White, separate and unequal. But the Commission
believed that it was “time to make good the promises of
American democracy to all citizens – urban and rural,
White and Black, Spanishsurname, American Indian, and
every minority group.”
The Commission saw the federal
government as the only institution with the moral
authority and resources to create change “at a scale
equal to the dimension of the problems.” The “most
persistent and serious grievances” were unemployment and
underemployment, in the view of the Commission.
Education and desegregation also were high priorities.
The Commission concluded that new attitudes, new
understanding, and, above all, “new will” would be
necessary to carry out its recommendations.
What Happened in the Last
Forty Years?
There are important
exceptions, but America has, for the most part, failed
to meet the Kerner Commission’s goals of less poverty,
inequality, racial injustice and crime:
Poverty
|
• 37
million Americans live in poverty today, in
the richest country in history.
• 46
million Americans are without health
insurance, and 36 percent of the poor
are unprotected.
• The child
poverty rate has increased slightly, from 15
percent in 1968 to 17 percent in 2006.
• For young
children (below 5 years old) the poverty
rate is almost 21 percent today.
• The
American child poverty rate is about 4 times
the average poverty rate for Western
European countries.
• Poverty
has deepened for those who have remained
poor. The proportion of the poor below half
the poverty line was about 30 percent in
1975 and 43 percent in 2006.
• Poor
African Americans are 3 times as likely and
poor Hispanics twice as likely as
non-Hispanic Whites to live in deep poverty,
below half the poverty line.
• The
poverty rate has declined for African
Americans since the Kerner Commission, but
poverty in African American female headed
households with children under 18 was almost
44 percent in 2006.
• The
Kerner Commission found that unemployment
and underemployment were the most important
causes of poverty, yet African American
unemployment has continued to be twice as
high as White unemployment during each of
the 4 decades since 1968.
• The
employment prospects of the nation’s
out-of-school 16-24 year old men have
declined considerably since 2000. The
problem is especially acute for young
African American men. Among high school drop
outs aged 19, only 38 percent of African
Americans are employed, compared to 67
percent of Whites.
|
Inequality: Income and Wealth
|
• The top 1
percent of the population (300,000
Americans) now receives as much income as
the lower one-half of the population (150
million Americans).
• Since the
late 1970s, the real after tax income of
those at the top of the income scale has
grown by 200 percent, while it has grown by
15 percent for those in the middle and 9
percent for those at the bottom.
• A recent
Brookings Institution study on mobility
found that 68 percent of White children from
middle income families grew up to surpass
their parents’ income in real terms. But
that share was only 31 percent for middle
income African American children –
demonstrating downward mobility.
• America
has one of the highest levels of income
inequality in the industrialized world.
• In terms
of wealth, America is the most unequal
country in the industrialized world. |
Inequality: Wages
|
• Over the
last 40 years, America has had the most
rapid growth in wage inequality in the
industrialized world.
• Since the
1970s, productivity has increased
significantly in America, but wages have
increased little in real terms. Corporations
are not sharing profits with workers, as had
been more the case, for example, in the late
1960s. From November 2001 through July 2006,
worker wages grew at an annual rate of 1.6
percent, while profits grew at an annual
rate of 14.4 percent.
• In the
1960s, the average CEO earned about 40 times
more than the average worker. Today, the
average CEO earns about 360 times as much.
• Among
full time workers, Whites earn over 22
percent more than equivalent African
American workers and almost 34 percent more
than equivalent Hispanic workers. |
Inequality: Education
|
• In
science achievement tests in 2003, American
students ranked 20th out of 40 countries.
• Large
disparities remain in America between the
educational achievement of White and Asian
American high school students compared to
Latino and African American high school
students.
• American
educational disparities remain linked to
funding disparities. The wealthiest 10
percent of school districts in the U.S.
spend nearly 10 times more than the poorest
10 percent.
• In the
U.S., the highest performing students from
low income families now enroll in college at
the same rate as the lowest performing
students from high income families. In other
words, the smartest poor kids attend college
at the same rate as the dumbest rich kids.
• The
American educational system allocates more
unequal inputs and produces more unequal
outcomes than most other industrialized
nations. |
Racial Injustice
|
• The
likelihood for the death sentence is greater
for minorities than Whites. Minorities
receive longer sentences than Whites for the
same crimes. Sentences for crack cocaine,
used disproportionately by minorities, have
been much longer than sentences for powder
cocaine, used disproportionately by Whites.
• There is
continuing evidence from distinguished
scholars that some employers “steer”
minority applicants into the worst jobs
regardless of their qualifications; that
many real estate agents steer minorities to
less desirable locations, compared to
Whites; and that lenders treat minorities
differently from Whites in terms of
percentage of mortgage applications
accepted.
• School
desegregation proceeded rapidly in America
from the 1960s to the 1980s and then was
dramatically reversed by the courts.
•
Residential segregation declined overall for
African Americans in the 1990s but it rose
for African Americans below age 18.
• Hispanic
residential segregation increased in many
major metropolitan areas from 1980 to 2000.
• Overall
levels of residential segregation remain
high for African Americans and Latinos. |
Crime
|
• The
percent of Americans reporting fear of
walking alone at night has increased from
about 31 percent in 1967 to about 38 percent
in 2006.
• The most
accurately reported crime is homicide. The
homicide rate in the 1960s was roughly the
same as it is today (5.1 per 100,000 in
1960, 6.2 in 1967 and 5.7 in 2006).
• This is
so in spite of an eight fold increase in the
total population of persons in prisons and
jails since the late 1960s. Well over
2,000,000 persons now are in American
prisons and jails. America has the highest
reported rate of incarceration in the world.
• African
American men aged 25 to 29 are almost 7
times as likely to be incarcerated as their
White counterparts.
• Today,
the rate of incarceration of African
American men in the U.S. is 4 times higher
than the rate of incarceration of African
American men in South Africa during the
pre-Nelson Mandela apartheid government.
• A
prison-industrial complex has developed. The
states collectively now spend more on prison
construction than on construction for higher
education.
• A
disproportionate number of ex-offenders
return from prison to a small number of
heavily impacted communities.
• The
national recidivism rate for persons
released from prison is over 67 percent.
• The late
1990s decline in violent crime has recently
reversed in many cities, based on a report
by the Police Executive Research Forum. |
Positive Trends Since the
Kerner Commission
As we dialogue on these
negative findings with citizens across the nation before
releasing our final report, it will be important to
acknowledge and debate the positive trends since the
Kerner Commission. For example, an African American is
running for President, and a Latino was a candidate in
the early 2008 primaries. Compared to the late 1960s,
substantial African American and Latino middle classes
have emerged, the number of minority entrepreneurs has
greatly expanded, and there are large numbers of
minority local and state elected officials.
How Have the Media Failed
the People?
Since the Kerner Commission,
media ownership has been reduced to just a few giant
corporations, facilitated by federal deregulation.
Corporate oligopolies now are threatening control of the
Internet. Billionaire media owners have a deep stake in
political outcomes. Minorities are greatly
underrepresented in the media. Minority ownership is
miniscule. Top heavy with White middle-class men,
television news departments and major newspapers today
are obsessed with ratings and profits. The priorities of
the Kerner Commission rarely come to the fore, and then
only for a short while, as the coverage of Hurricane
Katrina, New Orleans and the Jena 6 have illustrated.
(See eisenhowerfoundation.org for testimony from the
Eisenhower Foundation’s Kerner 40th hearings on the media.)
What New Policy Is Needed?
Polls have consistently shown
that most Americans believe the major obstacle to
progress is “lack of knowledge.” That is not so. In the
years since the Kerner Commission, we have learned a
great deal about what works and what doesn’t work.
Within a policy framework based on the values and
history of the American people, we therefore should seek
to replicate what works “to a scale equal to the
dimension of the problems” (to quote the Kerner
Commission) and stop doing what doesn’t work.
Our policy focus is on the
truly disadvantaged, the working class and the middle
class – because we seek an electoral alliance of
Americans broad enough to secure reform. The alliance
very much needs solidarity between Hispanics and African
Americans, who together now make up over 25 percent of
the population. Following Kerner priorities, we propose
economic, job, education, race specific, crime
prevention and targeted multiple solution policy
reforms, as follows:
Economic and Job Policy
Over the last 40 years,
inclusive, demand side economic policy that creates
tight labor markets has performed better for the poor
and for the nation as a whole than exclusionary
supply side policy that favors the rich and tells
average Americans “you’re on your own.” (See Attachment
1.)
We therefore need demand side
economic policy that empowers American workers and
communicates to the poor, working class and middle class
that “we’re in this together.”
The existing Humphrey-Hawkins
Full Employment Act should be strengthened to require
the Federal Reserve Board to take action whenever the
unemployment rate rises above 4 percent.
That will keep labor markets
tight.
The federal minimum wage
remains relatively low, and the impact is
disproportionate to lower income families. We need to
raise the minimum wage to one-half of the average wage
for blue collar workers and nonmanagers – and then to
index the rate to that level.
Especially given that the
official definition of poverty in America is absurdly
low ($21,386 for a family of 4), we need to enact
universal health care, which will disproportionately
help the poor. The federal government needs to increase
the Earned Income Tax Credit and to increase resources
for specific family budget items like housing and child
care.
Passage of the Employee Free
Choice Act, the most important labor law reform since
the Wagner Act, will add much needed balance to the
playing field for workers who seek to form unions in
workplaces – especially in industries where the truly
disadvantaged and minority workers are employed, like
service industries. Worker empowerment will fall short
without job skills and high school (or equivalency)
diplomas for the truly disadvantaged. Consistent with
the Kerner Commission’s call for a comprehensive
manpower and education policy, we need a new Employment
Training and Job Creation Act that replaces the present
Work Investment Act and the present “work first”
Temporary
Assistance for Needy Families program.
For the neediest, including
high school dropouts and welfare clients, the Employment
Training and Job Creation Act should fund replications
of grassroots, city, state and national youth job
training and job retention models that already have been
evaluated as successful or hold great promise as best
practices.*
But the Employment Training
and Job Creation Act also should provide working class
and middle class Americans with enhanced skills for
upward mobility and new skills when they lose their jobs
(especially when the cause is job loss to other
countries and globalization more generally).
Newly trained workers should
be directed to private sector jobs generated by tight
labor markets. In addition, America should finance
public sector employment in industries with great need –
including health care, housing development, public
infrastructure development, energy and high tech
sectors. America needs to end tax breaks for companies
that ship jobs oversees and give breaks to companies
that create good jobs with decent wages in the United
States.
Worker empowerment requires
building a democratic strategy against globalization,
beginning with a movement for a new social contract for
workers in North America.
The nation should legalize
permanent residence of and paths to citizenship for the
large numbers of law-abiding and hard-working immigrants
who now are living in America illegally. (One study
estimates the number at 12 million.) Immigrants
represent a critical resource for the American economy.
Maximum civic incorporation of immigrants is fundamental
to the American values of liberty, democracy and equal
opportunity.
Education Policy
America needs an Education
Equity Act that replaces the failed No Child Left Behind
law. No Child Left Behind has had little significant
success in either changing previously existing
educational trends or in diminishing the racial
achievement gap.
The federal government must
finance a system to create equity in dollar investment
per pupil across all school districts, as is done in
most advanced industrialized countries. All public
schools need comparable physical facilities, equipment,
teacher training, teacher compensation, class sizes and
curricula.
* Such
models include the Career Academies Program, the Career
Beginnings Program, Casa Verde Builders, the Center for
Employment Training, the Gulf Coast Trades Center, Job
Corps, the Latinos Stars Program, the Los Angeles Youth
Opportunity Movement, Moving Up, Project Opportunity,
Project Paycheck, the SoBRO Youth Development Center,
the Youth Career Program and YouthBuild USA.
A new Education Equity Act
should fully fund Head Start preschool for all eligible
poor children. We then need to replicate successful
state equity models, like Connecticut, which raised and
equalized teacher salaries, and North Carolina, which
recruited new teachers through service scholarships.
Most poor African Americans,
Hispanics and other minorities are offered curricula
geared primarily to “rote” memorization. The curricula
do not develop the skills in the new knowledge-based
economy that allow students to engage in independent
analysis and problem solving – and that will teach them
to communicate effectively. The Education Equity Act
needs to develop and equalize curricula based on the
successes in states like Connecticut, Kentucky, Maine,
Nebraska, Oregon and Vermont.
The Education Equity Act
should include a new Contract for College as articulated
by Demos, the public policy research and action
organization. The Contract would unify the existing
three strands of federal financial aid – grants, loans
and work-study – into a coherent, guaranteed financial
aid package for students. Grants would make up the bulk
of aid for students from low and moderate income
families. The Contract would recognize the important
value of reciprocity – so part of the Contract for every
student would include some amount of student loan aid
and/or some work-study requirements.
The Contract is designed to
re-orient federal aid back to a more grant-based system
and to ensure that students from all financial
backgrounds understand upfront the type of financial aid
that will be available.
Racial Desegregation Policy
There must be national, state
and local re-commitment to racial desegregation and
integration in our schools and communities, consistent
with the recommendations of the Kerner Commission.
School desegregation was
effectively halted by the Supreme Court’s 2007 Seattle
decision. But national surveys show that two thirds of
the population believes desegregation improves education
for minorities. A growing proportion of the population
is aware of and has accepted the research findings that
desegregation has a positive impact on Whites, as well,
according to the UCLA-based Civil Rights Project.
Such findings need to help
anchor a new grassroots movement, part of a Fair
Economic Deal (below), that pushes for change in elected
leadership. In turn, such change can be a stepping stone
for change in the makeup of the federal courts, leading
to reversal of the 2007 Supreme Court decision.
With schools and residential
segregation so intertwined, a new movement must renew
advocacy for housing desegregation. To succeed with a
comprehensive policy for stable, racially integrated
neighborhoods, we need to promote the ability of racial
minorities to move into White neighborhoods; encourage
White families to move into predominantly minority
neighborhoods; control market forces to insure that low
income (especially minority) families are not pushed out
of neighborhoods as a result of gentrification; and
reduce racial discrimination by key players in the
housing chain – including homebuilders, landlords,
lenders, brokers, real estate agents and insurance
companies.
Consistent with this
framework, the Eisenhower Foundation will dialogue in
coming months with leading advocates to explore a number
of new initiatives. For example, there is a need to:
|
• Widely
replicate and greatly expand successfully
evaluated “mobility programs” -- like the
Chicago Gautreaux program and the federal
Moving to Opportunity program – that use
Section 8 vouchers to encourage low income
and minority families to move into better
neighborhoods. We need to build more market
rate rental housing and use Section 8
vouchers to help minorities get access to
them.
• Reform
the Community Reinvestment Act and the Home
Mortgage Disclosure Act to subject private
mortgage lenders and homeowner insurance
companies to regulatory oversight – on
issues like predatory lending and redlining. |
Targeted Safe Haven
Investment Zone Policy
Federal, state and local
policy needs to shift away from expensive and
cost-ineffective prison building that continues the
present 67 percent-plus recidivism rate. We need to move
towards less expensive and more effective alternatives
in the community. We need to follow the model of the
state of Arizona which, years ago, began moving in this
direction.
Priority should be given to
best practice models that reintegrate ex-offenders when
they leave prison. These models secure high school
equivalency diplomas, train ex-offenders for employment,
find them productive jobs, and follow up to insure job
retention. The principles underlying these models
deserve much more widespread replication.*
Even more cost-beneficial are
prevention models at the grassroots that keep children
and youth out of trouble – so they never end up in
prison. Typically, these initiatives provide multiple
solutions – like crime and delinquency prevention, drug
prevention, school drop out prevention, school
performance improvement and positive youth development.**
*
Such models include the Center for Employment Opportunities,
Delancey Street, Dismas House, the Fortune Society,
Gemeinschaft Home, Opportunities for Success, Pioneer
Human Services and the Safer Foundation.
**
Just a few examples which have been positively evaluated and
deserve widespread replication include Centro Sister
Isolina Ferre in San Juan, the Challengers Boys and
Girls Club in Los Angeles, the Comer School Development
Plan nationally, the Dorchester Youth Collaborative in
Boston, the Dover Youth Safe Haven in New Hampshire,
Full Service Community Schools nationally, the Quantum
Opportunities program nationally, Youth Development in
Albuquerque, Youth Guidance in Chicago and Youth Safe
Haven-Police Ministation initiatives in many locations
across the nation.
A Safe Haven Investment Act
should be legislated that co-targets such models with
job training, job creation, ex-offender reintegration,
community policing, low and moderate income housing
development, public infrastructure development and
community-based banking initiatives. The co-targeting
should be in geographic areas of greatest need – like
the census tracks where the 4 million Americans in
deepest poverty live and the neighborhoods where high
numbers of ex-offenders return. Such Safe Haven
Investment Zones should build in part on the Harlem
Children’s Zone model created by Geoffrey Canada.
How to Finance Reform?
The policies proposed here
should be financed by changes in the American tax code
that generate significant revenues and simultaneously
reduce economic inequality. The changes rescind the
recent tax breaks for the wealthiest Americans and
eliminate corporate tax loopholes.
Our recommendations are based
on a policy paper written for the Eisenhower Foundation
by Dr. John Irons, Director for Research and Policy at
the Economic Policy Institute in Washington, DC. The
paper is found here as Attachment 2.
How To Change Political
Will?
The Kerner Commission called
for “new will” to carry out its vision. Today, the need
to change political will is even more necessary, and
difficult, because of the prevailing ideology that tells
citizens they’re on their own.
As we take these preliminary
findings to the American people over coming months, our
first priority therefore is to dialogue on how to change
political will. Little is possible without such change.
To begin the debate, we call
for a grassroots people’s movement for a Fair Economic
Deal. An electoral majority needs to be fashioned from
among the poor, working class and middle class – all of
whom value and benefit from our recommendations on
worker empowerment, jobs, education, health and physical
security. African Americans and Latinos are central to
the majority. Public morality defined as the common good
needs to be invoked. The movement must take the high
moral ground. (See
eisenhowerfoundation.org
for testimony at the
Foundation’s hearings in Washington, DC on public
morality.)
To be morally and politically
credible, a Fair Economic Deal must be effectively
communicated as integral to the American story.
What is the American story,
the American narrative, upon which a Fair Economic Deal
can be based? America was the first nation in history to
offer freedom through opportunity to every citizen,
however humble. Abraham Lincoln recognized how positive
government furthered opportunity, and so used public
funds for racial justice, land grants colleges and
public infrastructure development. Theodore Roosevelt
believed that making giant corporations accountable to
the people was an American moral value.
Responding to how the
unregulated market caused the Great Depression, Franklin
Roosevelt empowered the people with a social contract
that overcame fear and valued working together. John
Kennedy’s inaugural speech was a “trumpet summons” for
“peaceful revolution” by the people who, he said, needed
to value “what together we can do,” unselfishly for our
country.
The profiles in courage of
these Republican and Democratic presidents, and of great
social movement leaders like Martin Luther King and
Cesar Chavez, are needed today. If new American leaders
with such courage come forth, the movement for a Fair
Economic Deal can make some immediate progress with the
policies proposed in this preliminary report.
But
a new movement also must be realistic, and so must take
a decades-long strategic perspective. Building on the
American narrative, the movement for a Fair Economic
Deal must nurture and finance new grassroots leadership
with fresh vision in the electoral world and in the
world of nonprofit organization and advocacy. The
corrupting influence of money in day-to-day corporate
lobbying and in political campaigns must be dramatically
reduced. Progress must begin again on voting rights
reform. An infrastructure of nonprofit think tanks and
new hybrid institutions must be created to advance new
ideas, effectively communicate them and discredit
existing beliefs.
Alternative media must be
enhanced and existing media reformed – to expose the
failures in the ideology of the elite.
The American people are ready
to support a Fair Economic Deal. Many of the policy
recommendations in this report are embraced by
significant and continuing majorities of Americans
polled. Pew and Gallup polls show support for raising
the minimum wage, government relief for skyrocketing
college costs, and government guarantees for universal
health insurance, “even if it means repealing most of
the recent tax cuts [for the rich].” Daniel Yankelovich
has found, in the words of Bill Moyers, that a majority
of citizens want “social cohesion and common ground
based on pragmatism and compromise, patriotism and
diversity…”
Only 14 percent of American
workers believe they have secured the American Dream:
|
What happens to a dream deferred?
Does it dry up
Like a raisin in
the sun?
Or fester like a
sore –
And then run?
Does it stink like
rotten meat?
Or crust and sugar
over
Like a syrupy
sweet?
Maybe it just sags
Like a heavy load.
Or does it
explode?
Harlem[2]
Langston Hughes |
Source:
Eisenhower Foundation
* *
* * *
Response
Mackie on Kerner Report
"What we telling
about—with racism was not—one white person hating one
black—or all black people. We're talking about kind of
an institutional racism which existed. And where people
live in all white neighborhoods. Send their kids to all
white schools. Drive quickly through black section
maybe, or on the train, to a job where all their
associates are white. And don't see anything odd about
it."
This is an exact description, ratcheted up some, of
Jena, Louisiana, of today: The Black neighborhoods they
are not even franchised or incorporated within Jena as a
whole. Black families of these neighborhoods can't even
vote in Jena politics. The churches are segregated by
physical and psychological distance. Blacks might work
in Jena but they do not live there. If it's a Black kid
who is the player winning games for the high school home
team, he can't really believe it is his home team, even
though everyone looks up to him as long as he is on the
field. But then he returns to his unincorporated
neighborhood. All of this adds a new meaning to the
phrase "field" Niggra. And the white establish doesn't
believe they have a race problem and accuse Northern
journalists of exaggerating the circumstances.—Mackie
* *
* * *
The Lingering Tragedies of
the Kerner Report
|
It
seems Reverend Wright is being
rehabilitated. But, of course, he should
never have been demonized and vilified. His
danger to our morals and ethics has been
much exaggerated, as well as his danger to
the state.
CBS Chicago
I wish I could be
optimistic, but I was in the supermarket
today, and took a glance at the cover of one
of the tabloids. Obama and Wright together
and captioned as enemies of America.—Wilson |
The miraculous intrigues me,
though God is not so ready to talk to me as he is
Jeremiah Wright. Of course, cable news and toilet
tabloids undermine the little enthusiasm for the
spiritual one might possess. These media hyenas look
forward to, generate, and thrive on the worse in
society. They are always there to howl in the darkness
to frighten us away from the good. Millions will vote
against Obama because he's a black man, though they'll
say it is for other reasons. But fear is at the core of
it all. A black family in the White House remains a
farce for many. That cannot be avoided even in our more
enlightened times.
Blackness only sells well as
entertainment. Joy does not come easy in America. Black
as power remains a threat for many, even when it's just
one man on a lone highway. It will take more generations
to overcome thoroughly that kind of irrationality.
Unlike some on the black-hand side I do not consider
racism endemic to white persons or to America. Centuries
of training is not easily wiped away in a life time. We
still do not feel fully comfortable with one another,
even though in some cases our families have lived for
centuries in the same towns, the same counties, on the
same road. We do not visit one another in homes or
churches. Our family church is 138 years old and I’ve
never known any local white to come visit except for a
funeral or possibly a wedding and these came from afar.
Slavery and Jim Crow (white
supremacy) remain the bugbear under our rugs. South
Carolina on the statehouse grounds still flies the
Confederate flag, though a third of its citizens are
black. Lately, Florida acknowledged the brutality of its
past. But on the whole when it comes to black feelings,
black appreciation, still, many are less than
empathetic, especially for the black poor. One can say
that we who are educated and materially advanced have
become damn right callous. Read
Kerner Commission Report Forty Years After.
I am not an enthusiastic
supporter of black church leaders. I still find it
amazing that Obama got hooked up with Jeremiah Wright.
But Obama is a consummate politician and as politician
one has to settle somewhere, especially when an
electorate prefers a churchgoing politician. What better
than a non-black denominational black church, that
purports to work for the black poor and their best
interests. From all measures Wright and Obama have a
genuine fondness for each other beyond politics. This
PBS interview with Jeremiah might be of interest in
explaining aspects of their friendship (PBS
Interview)
What troubles me in the
Obama-Wright episode is how easily the cable news can
reduce exceptional persons to common criminals. We have
not only had Wright crushed in the last month or so but
we have had the governor of New York
Eliot Spitzer, as
has been wonderfully pointed out. In matters of race,
religion, and sex or any combination of them, and
possibly the exceptionalism of America, the emotions of
the public are so easily mangled to make the good the
worse, the worst the best. Did you note how Patrick
Buchanan was able to call Obama a "black hustler" and
nothing was said on these cable news channels in defense
of a U.S. Senator (A Brief for Whitey).
It is this kind of absolute reduction, that inward Abu
Ghraib syndrome, I find most disturbing among our white
leaders and leaders.
I do not say we have no
scoundrels among us. We each have at least one in our
own family. Dorothy Rice believes we Christians are
forgivers (all those years of slavery and Jim Crow) and
we are ever ready to embrace our neighbor however obtuse
(and criminal) they may have been, maybe to a fault. Few
of us in our personal lives rarely run across such
exceptional men as Obama and Wright (Christians
Are Forgivers: Obama as Healer).
Many of us too quickly exaggerate our love or our
hatred.
It's indeed
regrettable that men like Patrick Buchanan and those
white men of cable news and the toilet tabloids are
incapable of looking beyond the skins of their
neighbors, and when they are capable, they only find the
worst stereotypes. I am certain an Obama presidency will
continue to guarantee the idiocies and jollies of these
media pundits and babblers. Hopefully, in the next
decade, we will be well along on the road to solving the
lingering tragedies pointed out by the
Kerner Report.—Rudy
* * *
* *
* * * * *
 |
Super Rich: A Guide to Having it All
By Russell Simmons
Russell Simmons knows firsthand that
wealth is rooted in much more than the
stock
market. True wealth has more to do with
what's in your heart than what's in your
wallet. Using this knowledge, Simmons
became one of America's shrewdest
entrepreneurs, achieving a level of
success that most investors only dream
about. No matter how much material gain
he accumulated, he never stopped lending
a hand to those less fortunate. In
Super Rich, Simmons uses his rare
blend of spiritual savvy and
street-smart wisdom to offer a new
definition of wealth-and share timeless
principles for developing an unshakable
sense of self that can weather any
financial storm. As Simmons says, "Happy
can make you money, but money can't make
you happy." |
* * * * *
|
The New Jim Crow
Mass Incarceration in the Age of
Colorblindness
By Michele Alexander
Contrary to the
rosy picture of race embodied in Barack
Obama's political success and Oprah
Winfrey's financial success, legal
scholar Alexander argues vigorously and
persuasively that [w]e have not ended
racial caste in America; we have merely
redesigned it. Jim Crow and legal racial
segregation has been replaced by mass
incarceration as a system of social
control (More African Americans are
under correctional control today... than
were enslaved in 1850). Alexander
reviews American racial history from the
colonies to the Clinton administration,
delineating its transformation into the
war on drugs. She offers an acute
analysis of the effect of this mass
incarceration upon former inmates who
will be discriminated against, legally,
for the rest of their lives, denied
employment, housing, education, and
public benefits. Most provocatively, she
reveals how both the move toward
colorblindness and affirmative action
may blur our vision of injustice: most
Americans know and don't know the truth
about mass incarceration—but her
carefully researched, deeply engaging,
and thoroughly readable book should
change that.—Publishers
Weekly |
 |
* * * * *
The White Masters of the
World
From
The World and Africa, 1965
By W. E. B. Du Bois
W. E. B. Du Bois’
Arraignment and Indictment of White Civilization
(Fletcher)
* *
* * *
Ancient African Nations
* * * * *
If you like this page consider making a donation
* * * * *
Negro Digest /
Black World
Browse all issues
1950
1960
1965
1970
1975
1980
1985
1990
1995
2000
____ 2005
Enjoy!
* * * * *
The Death of Emmett Till by Bob Dylan
/
The Lonesome Death of Hattie Carroll
/
Only a Pawn in Their Game
Rev. Jesse Lee Peterson Thanks America for
Slavery /
George Jackson /
Hurricane Carter
* *
* * *
The Journal of Negro History issues at Project Gutenberg
The
Haitian Declaration of Independence 1804
/
January 1, 1804 -- The Founding of
Haiti
* * * * *
* *
* * *
posted 1 April 2008
|