ChickenBones: A Journal

for Literary & Artistic African-American Themes

   

Home   isit Our Store (Books, DVDs, Music, and more)

Google
 

 Dyson did this piece Why I Love Black Women that was so shameless it was a farce.

 

 

Books by Tavis Smiley

 

My Story of Growing Up in America / The Covenant with Black America  /  The Covenant in Action

 

Never Mind Success: Go for Greatness  /  Keeping the Faith   /  Black Rage, Black Redemption

 

*   *   *   *   *

Books by Cornel West

Democracy Matters: The Fight Against Imperialism  /  Race Matters  / Cornel West Reader  /  The Future of the Race  

The American Evasion of Philosophy  /  African American Religious Thought  /  The War Against Parents 

The African American Century White on White / Black on Black  / Prophesy Deliverance  / The Soul Knows No Bars

*   *   *   *   *

Pass the Mic! Tour 

Responses to Editorial

 

My boy Tolbert up in Philly, though I haven't read his piece, I understand he didn't like the "Pass The Mic" tour.  Can't wait to see yours. 

Charles Siler

*   *   *   *   *

Outlaws and Superstars: Cornel, Tavis, Michael Eric and Rudy

By Arthur R. Flower

Recently my boy Rudy over at ChickenBones did a review of a Black Superstar Review touring Baltimore in which three black public intellectuals, Cornel West, Tavis Smiley, and Michael Eric Dyson did a show at Baltimores Lryic Theatre.

Clearly Rudy was not impressed. I understand his irritation. Apparently they came out rocking and rolling a blend of hiphop preaching like they do before an adoring crowd of over a thousand blackfolk at $60 a pop. (Surely $20 would have been sufficient.) Got to give the brothers their propers, their heart is good, and they perform a service. But it irritates those of us laboring unappreciated in the vineyards to see Slick get over like it does today.

Mostly because it reflects a grievous African American loss of direction in the Struggle and where we are as a People when Media Superstardom defines our leadership.

Which in order to be anointed must almost by definition have to be shallow and commercially inclined. (Or demagogic and bombastic foolishness).

I like Cornel and I think he plays a significant role but I remember when him and Skip Gates did a book called The Future of the Race and I picked it up looking to see something real and it was like academic popcorn. I was offended that they had wasted a good title like that.

I try my best to be Serious and Significant and whenever I Speak I try to make a Contribution and I get ignored by everybody. I carry the prophetic curse. I speak and no one listens.

Makes you wonder sometime if you wasting your time and need to focus on making a living like everybody else instead of trying to Save the Race. Trying to be Serious and not just Pandering to the Crowd and the Times. Dyson did this piece Why I Love Black Women that was so shameless it was a farce. These the people everybody jumping up and down about. Cause they got their media game together. I too respect and admire these brothers at their Best. Cause they Committed and they got Game. Ive tried but I just cant get no traction. Emerge Magazine once did a piece on invisible black male writers and I didnt even make the Invisible List.

Oh well. Aint no sense in being upset that folk dont see my Vision. Thats why they call it a Vision. But its hard sometime not to resent it when you just got to sit there and watch Bullshit Walk.

I hear folk talk of public intellectuals and its hard not to sneer. A buddy of mine once said I was an Outlaw. I was offended, "I aint no Outlaw" I told her. She said, I didnt say you were a Criminal, I said you were an Outlaw. Since Ive known you youve operated outside of the system.

Ive since embraced the term. Outlaw Intellectual. Rather proud of it. Cause I know Im doing what Im supposed to do. Im making my contribution like my mentor, John O Killens, another unappreciated warrior, trained me to do. Ima Do What I Do and hope that History treats me better than my Own Times have.

And am I sometimes dismayed by the media superstar leadership mode that has left us directionless in these perilous times. But Ima keep my Perspective.

Cause I am even more Dismayed that Im not one of them.

I hope one day to get some play, a larger platform from which to make my points and get taken seriously.

And I hope that if I ever do get some play that I dont lose sight of whats Real. Ima keep the Faith. Like John O Killens taught me to.

I am a Master of the Longgame and Im proud of it. And whatever price it cost me to be Real, to be True Force, Im willing to pay it.

Thats why folk like Rudy and myself and the folk over at The Black Commentator and Freedom Rider have begun to forge our own vehicles for Speaking Truth to the People.

I often feel that I am speaking to the void with Rootsblog but Ive decided to maintain it at least a year without whining or worrying about my lack of acknowledgement for what I do - for my efforts to make a contribution. By then I hope it will just be a habit.

Cause I am a child of the 60s and I believe in the Struggle. I am a Drummajor for Righteousness and Ima do what Im Supposed To Do and Im not going to worry about not getting no props for it.

History will Absolve me.

I am Flowers of the Delta Clan Flowers and the Line of O Killens.

I am an Outlaw.

   

*   *   *   *   *

Mon, 22 Dec 2003 

Rudy: 

I have read, in fact, your editorial on the tres amigos now several times. Although, I don't agree with you in total, your arguments are sound.  You have a beautiful mind.  I think if you ever met Cornel West, you might have a different opinion of him.  I have a friend who met Cornel and had a totally different opinion of him after meeting him.

I don't think Travis is in the same league, that is, intellectually as West and Dyson.  I think Travis is really more of the entrepreneur of the three. I would agree with you that $60.00 is much too much money to hear a speech with Travis, Dyson, or West. I do know, in the case of West, that he has donated all the money from one of his books to a very worthy cause.  I have the book at home.  It was a book he edited with a young scholar. Have a great holiday! As ever, Herbert

*   *   *   *   *

Friday, 19 Dec 2003 

I just read your editorial on Dyson, West & Smiley. Wonderful! Thank you! We need(ed) that!!! Take care. Happy New Year! Later, Louis

*   *   *   *   *

rudy

read your review of the three amigos you the man. i love knowing folk who got the courage to say what we all know to be the truth when the emperors walking around naked in these perilous times you go boy im proud to be your comrade in arms arf

*   *   *   *   *

Hotep brotha! Just read your analysis on the "Pass the Mic Tour" on your great web site. Although I know you were being objective, Imma say it: dem Negroes ain't trying to liberate the people!

But I wanted to say that it was an excellent review and I really enjoyed it. How can I get a copy(VHS or audio) of that event? Did u tape it?

Recently Bob Law was in my city of St. Louis, I will soon submit my analysis on that talk to a number of outlets including yours. Law was da bomb. a true warrior indeed. maybe you and I can share(trade) knowledge materials cuz I did tape Bob's lecture. Warmest, Njai

*   *   *   *   *

Monday, 15 Dec 2003 

Peace,

I guess I was damned lucky not to have gone to the Pass the Mic thing. I asked Bilal to go with me but he was otherwise tied up. So, I pocketed the money and went home. I was so tired I fell asleep and didn't  wake up until 1am. Your analysis is what mine would have been. I just wanted confirmation of my suspicions that all the current and all too much promoted leadership has nothing going for it. You saved me a lot of anguish and late hours of writing. I thank you for that and congratulate you on the article.

Secondly, your interchange with Joe seems to be bearing some fruit. And, I guess this is good. But, as they say, it is hard for a leopard to change his spots or an Ethiopian his skin. So, we will have to see how Joe does in the future. He very well may not be able to do any better despite his best intentions. The fact that he seems to be almost universally despised is something that I suspected. I must commend you for your tact. But, I suspect

you were up to something when you placed his article next to mine. The thing is that I respect Joe's courage and persistence. On the other hand, these are the qualities that make him so adamant and stubborn in outlook. But only time, will tell. I understand that you are going home for the holidays. Be safe and get some rest. amin sharif

*   *   *   *   *

 

 

 

 

 

 

update 23 June 2008

 

 

Home Baltimore Page  Dietrich Bonhoeffer  Table

Related files: Cornel West Moves to Princeton  West Cites Reason For Quitting  Cornel West: An Editorial  Pass the Mic  Responses to Pass the Mic

The Tavis Smiley Presidential Forum