ChickenBones: A Journal

for Literary & Artistic African-American Themes

   

Home  

Google
 

 

Responses to Skip Gates

"Two Nations" and the "Talented Fifth"

 

 

 

Books by Henry Louis Gates, Jr.

 

Colored People Our Nig / The African American Century The Bondwoman's Narrative  / Thirteen Ways of Looking at a Black Man

 

The Trials of Phillis Wheatley "Race," Writing, and Difference  / Wonders of the African World

 

In Search of Identity  /  Speaking of Race, Speaking of Sex  /  The Signifying Monkey

 

Cosmopolitanism / Identity and Violence / The Norton Anthology of African American Literature

 

*   *   *   *   *

 

 

Dear Rudy,

For a variety of reasons, mostly my own fault, I have just read your piece on Skip Gates. Thanks a million.

You have also given me some ammunition for a column which I will be writing in a little while about an issue which I call "Slave Society in the 21st century". You need wider exposure outside of the US. Peace and Love —John

*   *   *   *   *

RL, peace!

Skip Gates is part of a flanking effort being made by conservatives on one side and middle/upper class sellouts on the other side. It is my opinion that we are entering a new phase of struggle that will divide Black folk along class lines. This is why I said that we must know where middle and upper class blacks allegiance lie. As far as Skip is concerned, I am fed up with his bs and uncle tom antics. I have decided to boycott the programs. —amin sharif

*   *   *   *   *

Greetings Brother Lewis,

I appreciate your emails and keep them coming. But you have got to be kidding about watching anything Gates presents after the outrageous hatchet job he did for white america in that showing about Africa. He was dogged by conscience African descendants all over america after he did the hatchet job on Africa. Serious African descendants don't need "skip gates" who obvious helps to redefine the white supremacy system values in such ways many whites would dare not do to help prop up their system.

If people don't understand how the white Harvard University well funds this man gates to go out step and fetch it for them under the guise of scholarship and higher education, then our people don't understand how the white supremacy system power keepers operate.

The beyond the color line bullshit is only more confusing. The white supremacy system domination is the underlying factor of the white power structure. Being in bed with persons classified as white, causes most "black" persons who are hooked up with them to make compromising comments and actions while the white supremacy system power keepers go on dominated people of color around the world. That's what colin powell helped them do then and is helping them do now. The white supremacy domination system survives by dealing on color.

As Dr. Frances Cress Welsing stated back in the 1980s at Stanford University, in the white supremacy domination chessboard game, white people play on the white side of the board. Too many black people try to play in the middle of racism chessboard game, even some claiming to be white or at least color blind. What's needed and must be is the type of blacks who will play on the black side of the white supremacy domination with its racism behavior side of the board and checkmate white supremacy.

Skip Gates, yes skip him, ain't playing on the black side of the white supremacy chessboard game, he is in the middle and as the coloreds of Southern Africa was and is still being used as a buffer to better the white supremacy system power keepers to keep on, this beyond color business is just more of the same.

In fact this defect goes back to the days when the Portuguese invaded Africa in the 15th century and intentionally jumped in bed with black women to produce children who identified with their white daddies and helped them do the dirty work of seducing Africa. If you don't understand this age old color thing, then skip gates and em are only going to confuse the hell out of you. —Ser Boxley

*   *   *   *   *

Dear Rudy:

I just read your editorial on Gates .  I agree with most of what you have to say.  The only comment I have to make is that the mothers and fathers who manage to give their children a tremendous dose of self esteem, whatever their circumstances, seem to be the parents with the most capable adults.  This is hard to do - poor or rich - too many variables.  Bad stuff happens along the way.

However, I do believe if the child is short he or she should be told the advantages of being short.  The same goes for anything else the world hands us.  Unfortunately, none of us are perfect parents and we all make excuses for our children and ourselves.  Inevitably we make mistakes and the buck stops here. 

It is comforting to have someone else to blame it on, and God knows white America has a lot to be ashamed of.   But the more we blame, rather like a marital quarrel, the more backlash there is.   all best, —Lee 

*   *   *   *   *

It is strange, but in a sense Gates has this same class biased sociology of Du Bois "talented tenth" which he inherited from Lenin's concept of the "bourgeois intelligentsia" leading the "proletarian revolution".  I'm sure that Du Bois and Lenin would roll in their graves if they saw the shit that their ideas led to -- Lenin to Stalin, Du Bois' "talented tenth" to Gates "talented "one-fifth". Your critique of Gates is very comprehensive as it stands. It's unbelievable that he would expose the bourgeois mentality and elitism of the "black bourgeoisie" in public. But I guess he's no different than C Thomas and the other Black Republicans. But this trend is the opposite of Du Bois who argued that the educated elite had a social and political obligation to the masses of less fortunate Blacks whereas, as you showed, Gates is telling the Black bourgeoisie to tell the masses to kiss their asses. —Joe

*   *   *   *   *

Brother Rudy:

I must have entered Harvard at the same time he entered Yale only I was not a middle class, I was dirt poor. My route to Harvard was different than Schmoke and Gate’s path to Yale. 

 My father was a construction worker, and my mother was a fulltime homemaker.  She had to be with eleven children, and a sick mother-in-law residing at 306 S. Fremont Avenue.  When I was presented with the idea of going away from home to a place where I could get 3 square meals, a bed of my own, and a good education, I  got down on my knees every evening and prayed to Almighty God for this dream to come true.  When I got the letter of acceptance , I ran up and down Fremont avenue shouting for joy.

Through prep school, I smiled all the time because I was in a wonderland. Because I was one of two African-Americans at the school, I experienced more economic than racial prejudice. I remember the first marking period, I had a D- average, but with first class effort marks.  I was so embarrassed .  I quietly vowed and prayed that this would change and it did.  By the end of my senior year, I had a cumulative average of B- and was on my way to Harvard. 

 It was only at fair Harvard that I started to hear about something that Gates omitted, namely the controversy of racial inferiority as proposed by Prof. Hernstein during the 70’s.  I began to doubt my own abilities,  even as society sought academic justification for my inferiorities. I had to reach out to God again on my knees for the ground of reason and truth that was not available in academic society and certainly not the society at large. God answered like Jesse said, “I am somebody!”  I went on to graduate cum laude, with a degree in mathematics and with skepticism that the culture at large can entertain the TRUTH.

Du Bois had the talented tenth, and now Gates has doubled it to make it a talented fifth.  I guess that is his idea of progress.   

At this point in my life, having come a ways from the poverty of my youth, I can truly say that the only reason I can now stomach the lynchings of the past, the drugs of the present, the cruelties of the war, the futilities of our lives is  my Lord and Savoir Jesus Christ who brought me through prep school, Harvard and professional life.  Jesus is my reason for being; my answer for the absurd society in which I live.  peace and all good to you and yours,  —will

*   *   *   *   *

Wow, Rudy,  

That was good! Well written and compassion for the masses and hostility to those who call themselves "Black" to advance their careers and turn around and attack us once they get there. I am reminded of Clarence Thomas attacks on his sister on welfare supporting his mother. Or something like that. Great writing.  Joe

*   *  *   *   *

As they say in N'yawlins (or in the words of our mutual friend Kalamu): "Yeah, you right!"  —Chuck

*   *   *   *   *

Hey brotha Rudolph!

Wanted to send a shout out on your recent article concerning Henry Louis Gates. Good reading, right on point and I loved it.

Warmest,  —Njai

*   *   *   *   *

you tickle me
i thought i was the only one up burning
that midnight oil
trying to stay ahead of the game    in struggle—arf

*   *   *   *   *

I assume your article was inspired by Skip's appearance on Charlie Rose last night?   Fast work!  By now, I suppose everybody has seen through Skip--well almost everybody.  He continues to be a popular speaker.   Yours faithfully, —Wilson

*   *   *   *   *

Henry Louis Gates, Jr. on DVD

 

DVD Description of  America beyond the Color Line

Henry Louis Gates Jr. travels the length and breadth of the United States to take the temperature of black America at the start of the new century. Gates visits the East Coast, the deep South, inner-city Chicago and Hollywood to explore the rich and diverse landscape, social as well as geographic.

*   *   *   *   *

DVD Description of African American Lives


Renowned scholar Dr. Henry Louis Gates Jr., W.E.B. DuBois professor of the Humanities and chair of African and African-American Studies at Harvard University, takes Alex Haley’s Roots saga to a whole new level. Using genealogy and DNA science, Dr. Gates tells the personal stories of eight accomplished African Americans, tracing their roots through American history and back to Africa. Participants include Dr. Ben Carson, Whoopi Goldberg, Bishop T.D. Jakes, Dr. Mae Jemison, Quincy Jones, Dr. Sara Lawrence-Lightfoot, Chris Tucker and Oprah Winfrey.

*   *   *   *   *

 

DVD Description of  Wonders of the African World

Africa is a continent of magnificent treasures and cultures--from the breathtaking stone architecture of 1,000-year-old ruins in South Africa to an advanced 16th century international university in Timbuktu. However, for centuries, many of these African wonders have been hidden from the world, lost to the ravages of time, nature and repressive governments. Uncover the richness of these African Wonders with Henry Louis Gates, Jr. as he explores the many cultures, traditions and history of the African continent.

*   *   *   *   *

 

 

 

Home  The Du Bois-Malcolm-King

Related files:  Noise of Class Ideology  Responses to Skip Gates' The Talented Fifth   Master of the Intellectual Dodge