|
Books by C. Liegh McInnis
Scripts: Sketches and Tales of Urban Mississippi /
Da Black Book of Linguistic Liberation /
Confessions: Brainstormin' from
Midnite 'til Dawn
Matters of reality: Body, mind & soul /
Prose: Essays and Personal Letters
/
Searchin' for Psychedelica
The Lyrics of Prince: A Literary Look at a Creative,
Musical Poet, Philosopher, and Storyteller
*
* * * *
Who or What Does
The Help Help?
A Brief Review by
C. Liegh McInnis
Okay, so I finally finished the
four hundred and forty-four pages that constitute
Kathryn
Stockett’s
The Help. An older African
(American) female colleague gave me this book a year ago
to thank me for providing a tutorial for a program that
she coordinates. I could not believe that anyone who
knew anything about me would give me a book written by a
white woman, telling the story of African (American)
maids working during the 1960s who collaborate with an
aspiring white female writer to tell their stories of
working for white women, essentially using African
people as backdrop or troping material for her story in
the way that
Tennessee Williams did more than a few
times. And for eleven months it sat on my shelf, not
even in its correct alphabetized-by-authors place as I
keep all my books but on the end where miscellaneous
books reside. Even as I heard about the book being a
New York Times Bestseller and then, of course, having a
movie based on it, I was never once tempted to take it
down and see just how much like Gone with the Wind it
could be. Yet when my wife took me to see Jumping the
Broom as an apology for dragging me to see the current Madea film (I like
Why Did I Get Married?,
Family that
Preys, and
For Colored Girls, but the current one just
doesn’t do it for me.), one of the previews was for
The
Help.
Often, of course, movie trailers lie well,
including the best scenes or moments in the promo of a
film that is a hour and a half dud. However, there are
some trailers that when one sees them one knows that the
studio has put all of its eggs, weight, and budget
behind this film. It is obvious when a film has been
given the first-class treatment. Again, a potential
viewer may not be able to tell whether or not the film
will be any good, but one can tell how much the studio
believes in the film based on the trailer and additional
promotion. It was that reality that said to me, “At
some point someone who loves this book and movie will
ask you about it; don’t you want to have enough
ammunition to dismiss it as more white fantasy with a
white female protagonist bonding with African women over
the brutality of men, especially African men, saving
themselves from the oppression of men, especially
African men?” So nine days ago, I opened to page one.
The Help
is a well-written book by a well-schooled writer,
Kathryn
Stockett, who has a
wonderful eye for detail (historical and cultural), a
flare for imagery (descriptive and symbolic), and a wit
that echoes three of my favorite storytellers:
Richard
Pryor,
Bill Cosby, and
Jerry Clower, especially in the
notion that a story with interesting and well-developed
characters is always more rewarding than a work of
fiction that is more concerned with showing the latest
“new school” tricks of fiction, especially as it relates
to
East Coast minimalism. Further, well-crafted books
are books that can be taught on two levels, and
The Help
achieves this. It can be used to teach the basic
elements of fiction writing, and it can be used to show
how creative writing is often crafted to enlighten or
impact socio-political condition, proving Du Bois to be
right that in the final analysis
“all art is propaganda”
(757).
The Help does not rise to the levels of
James
Baldwin,
Toni Morrison, or
James F. Cooper, but whose
work does? Certainly, not mine. However, Stockett has
mastered the weaving of the personal and communal
narrative and the ability to paint the complexities of
race rather than to pander to flat, one-dimensional
ideologies and characters, which is achieved by her
ability to craft characters in a storm of internal and
external conflict, for the most part, on both sides of
the race line.
When I read any work, I am always trying
to discover two elements: creative techniques that I
can use and teach to students, which I have briefly
discussed, and a central issue or several issues that
can be used in the development of a paper. Stockett has
presented at least twelve issues that can be discussed
in a lit crit piece: the perpetuation of fantasy
antebellum society for which whites are willing to lose
their humanity to maintain (such as in Faulkner’s
Sound
and the Fury), Christianity as a tool of white
supremacy, Christianity as a linguistic battleground for
Civil Rights, storytelling as socio-political activism
(which includes Aibileen—a maid and co-narrator of the
text—as a griot or the creative writer as shepherd and
philosopher), the tragedy of an unfulfilled life due to
embracing the physical over the metaphysical, African
(American) maids as another “Nigger Jim” figure, a
general commentary on poor and proper parenting or
negligent white mothers having enough money to hide
their poor parenting, white supremacy as schizophrenia
passed to and manifested in African people as colorism
or self-hatred, the manner in which African (American)
intellect and culture has existed despite and beyond
white culture and oppression as an example of African
intellect and culture existing before white culture, the
truth and importance of acknowledging African diversity
as complex and layered beings (which speaks to their
humanity as
Margaret Walker does with and for the slaves
in
Jubilee), the struggle of good-intentioned whites to
overcome their own racism, and (of course) the troping
or connecting of African oppression with female
oppression (allowing the book to be a manifesto on the
plight of the female under male oppression). Each of
these themes is well painted through intricate character
development and creative plot weaving.
There seems to be only two flaws,
and both can be considered major. The first issue is
the use of faulty or flawed dialect, specifically
Stockett’s use of “Law” for “Lawd” as in “Lawd have
mercy.” I have been unable to finish a few books
wherein I found flawed or inauthentic dialect, but in
this case it does not seem to bother me as much,
probably because there are no other glaring dialect
issues. Also, I realize that I am reading a book
through a white writer’s eyes (even though the narrative
is equally shared by two maids and a recent white female
college graduate), and I can accept that to her ears she
does not hear the “d” in “Lawd.” Because there is not
an abundance of flaws in the dialect, I am not
distracted from the narrative though a few of my friends
and colleagues have been too distracted to even finish
chapter one. Secondly, I agree with
Ishmael Reed that,
in most cases, white feminists use the African male as
the face of sexism. And I cannot help but wonder if
this is true in
The Help.
While she is clear, vivid,
and precise about the horrors of racism that
Afro-Southerners endure in the 1960s, Stockett presents
two positive adult white males (Skeeter’s father and
Celia’s husband) and not one positive adult African
male. There are two male sons of maids that are
portrayed in a positive manner, but neither achieves
maturity as a sovereign adult male: one dies in an
accident, and one is beaten until he is blind. In fact,
the one African male whom Stockett develops as more than
a symbol of the Civil Rights Movement is Leroy, the
husband of Minny, and he beats Minny regularly. Is
there not one maid whose husband does not beat her? Is
there not one average African male who is not a threat
to his community? And as a well-skilled craftsman,
Stockett appropriates and connects Leroy’s evil with the
evil of white male sexism and schizophrenia, especially
when Minny and Celia, Minny’s boss, are attacked by an
insane, naked white man. Yet, in combining the two
events to develop her theme of universal or female
oppression and struggle, Stockett seemingly paints Leroy
and all African men with a broader, more stereotypical
stroke than white men. The insane, naked white man in
Celia’s backyard is never equated with all other white
men. However, just before the insane, naked white man
appears, Stockett has Celia showing concern for Minny’s
plight, even attempting to come to Minny’s aid:
|
“Minny?” Miss Celia says, eyeing
the cut again. “Are you sure you [cut your forehead] in
the bathtub?” I run the water just to get some noise in
the room. “I told you I did and I did. Alright?” She
gives me a suspicious look and points her finger at me.
“Alright, but I’m fixing you a cup of coffee and I want
you to just take the day off, okay?…You know,” she says
kind of low, “You can talk to me about anything, Minny.”
(304-305). |
During the attack by the insane,
naked white man, Stockett connects Minny’s beating from
Leroy to the beating that she takes from the insane,
naked white man: “It’s like he knows me, Minny
Jackson. He’s staring with his lip curled like I
deserved every bad day I’ve ever lived, every night I
haven’t slept, every blow Leroy’s ever given. Deserved
it and more” (305). And after Celia comes to Minny’s
aid, in the similar way that Skeeter, the book’s white
co-protagonist, comes to the aid of and provides voice
to the maids, Stockett connects, once again, Minny’s
beating by Leroy to the beating by the insane, naked
white man, but does so in a manner that can be seen as
painting the majority of African males with this
stereotypical brush:
|
“‘So what you gone do about it?’ Aibileen asks and I know she means the eye. We don’t
talk about me leaving Leroy. Plenty of black men leave
their families behind like trash in a dump, but it’s
just not something the colored women do” (310 – 311).
|
Stockett is careful to have her character use “plenty”
rather than most, but the message is received,
especially since there are no white women who exist in
physically abusive relationships in the novel. And
because her own, childhood maid and caretaker was
“married to a mean, abusive drinker,” then that must be
the lasting image of African men in her novel. In fact
for all of the fear and potential consequence the
African women face from providing stories for the book,
it seems that the greatest threat comes from Leroy, as
Minny states: “Look, Aibileen, I ain’t gone lie. I’m
scared Leroy gone kill me if he find out” (429). And
when Leroy discovers that he has been fired from his job
because of Minny contributing stories to the book, of
course, all black savage Negro hell breaks out: “Minny
panting and heaving. ‘He throw the kids in the yard and
lock me in the bathroom and say he gone light the house
on fire with me locked inside!” (437).
Thus, escaping
life with Leroy, who by now has become the face of all
African men, is as important as escaping white
supremacy: “Still, what’s important is, Minny’s away
from Leroy” (439). Whether Stockett knows it or not,
this representation of African domestic violence is just
one more use of writing as skin privilege, one more use
of writing as a smokescreen to keep hidden the obscene
abusive relationships that do exist in “white” marriages
and partnerships. Stokett writes well, but she runs the
risk of hopelessly reinforcing ideas of white supremacy,
even if she does so unconsciously. Additionally, those
who have profited from reading
Dessa Rose,
Beloved, and
The Autobiography of Miss Jane Pittman—works that deal
with recording someone else’s story—may find that Stockett has consciously or unconsciously used the
African male body as a symbol or smokescreen for all
evil or merely to placate the supremacy of her white
readers.
Furthermore what Stockett seems to miss or
forget is that the power of the maids’ storytelling is
the balance that their story brings to the American
narrative. What was wrong with Amos and Andy is not
that they existed but that they existed alone with no
different narrative to balance or provide a well-rounded
notion of African people. Accordingly, white people are
not offended or threatened by
The Beverly Hillbillies
because Marcus Welby, Ward and June, and
Ozzie and
Harriet provided a counter-narrative to paint a holistic
portrait of white Americans. In fact, within The
Beverly Hillbillies exists the counter-narrative of
Milburn Drysdale and Jane Hathaway. Yet, for
The Help,
one can leave with the notion that African women should
fear African men as much as they should fear the evils
of white supremacy.
As one who has engaged countless
books, I have developed the ability to take what is
well-done or beneficial from a work and ignore what is
poorly done or what is not effective. For instance, I
continue to enjoy two hundred and twenty-one of the two
hundred and forty-two pages of African (American) poet
and theorist Carl Phillips’ book
Coin of the Realm:
Essays on the Life and Art of Poetry. Not only do I not
agree with the twenty-one pages that constitute the
chapter “Boon and Burden: Identity in Contemporary
American Poetry,” in which he provides his assessment of
the poetry of the Black Arts Movement, I find his
attempt to couch his subjective denouncement of the
poetry of the Black Arts Movement as objective theory to
be thin and flimsy. However, the rest of the book is a
worthwhile read.
In this same manner, Stockett’s
painting African men in such broad strokes does not
completely destroy the narrative for me. There was no
way to expect a southern white writer, even one
self-exiled to New York, to indict solely white men or
white culture for the evils of the South. Besides, the
Negro boogeyman still sells as well as sex does. For
chronological and cultural context she evokes the names
of Medgar Evers and
Martin Luther King, Jr., even as
they are moreso flat, one-dimensional symbols of the
moment or the meaning of the moment, but there is no
adult African male who rises to the humanity and
goodness of Skeeter’s father and Celia’s husband.
Still, what saves the narrative is her wonderful use of
imagery, her ability to construct complex characters for
complex times—especially the manner in which Skeeter is
forced to realize and engage her own racist tendencies
and sensibilities, the presentation of Aibileen and
Minny as intellectual equals to Skeeter—especially their
full development into storytellers, the novel's biting
humor, and the unflinching portrayal of the horrors
endured by African people in America, showing the Klan
and white southern culture to be equal to the Taliban.
After completing the manuscript, Aibileen and Minny are
finally able to impress on Skeeter the seriousness of
their endeavor:
|
The room grows quiet. It’s dark
outside the window. The post office is already closed
so I brought [the manuscript] over to show to Aibileen
and Minny one last time before I mail it…“What if they
find out?” Aibileen says quietly…We haven’t talked about
this in a while…we haven’t really discussed the actual
consequences besides the maids losing their jobs. For
the past eight months, all we’ve thought about is just
getting it written… “Minny, you got your kids to think
about,” Aibileen says…[Skeeter says] “Aibileen, do you
really think they’d…hurt us? I mean, like what’s in the
papers?” Aibileen cocks her head at me, confused. She
wrinkles her forehead like we’ve had a
misunderstanding. “They’d beat us. They’d come out
here with baseball bats. Maybe they won’t kill us
but…’” (365-366). |
As Stockett echoes in the postlude,
“Too Little, Too Late,” “In
The Help there is one line
that I truly prize: ‘Wasn’t that the point of the
book? For women to realize, We are just two people.
Not that much separates us. Not nearly as much as I’d
thought’” (451). For Stockett,
The Help seems to be a
commentary and celebration of the “universality” of
humanity, especially the plight of women in a sexist
world. And while I agree more with
Langston Hughes’s
notion of “universality” from his seminal essay, “The
Negro Artist and the Racial Mountain,” that
“universality” is more of a trap or ploy to create
within African people an “urge within the race toward
whiteness, the desire to pour racial individuality into
the mold of American standardization, and to be as
little Negro and as much American as possible” (1267), I
can applaud Stockett for attempting to tell her truth,
which is another motif of the novel, and for having her
protagonist struggle with that truth in much the same
manner as Baldwin does in
Evidence of Things Not Seen.
Skeeter struggles with her relationship with Minny who
is not as placating as Aibileen, and she struggles with
just how much truth she tells about her own mother’s
relationship with their former maid, Constantine, who
was like a mother to her. Yet, what makes Skeeter
heroic is not that she single-handedly saves or leads
Aibileen and Minny or becomes the lone wolf against the
backlash of her white community but that she continues
her journey toward self-discovery as she continues her
journey to learn every aspect about the community that
has birthed and molded her, even when the journey does not
promise anything but the truth, which very well may be a
truth that will disrupt the foundation of the life she
knows.
The Help is already a
New York
Times Bestseller and will probably be a summer block
buster. And while I wonder if this same book would be
loved if written by an African woman, especially
considering that even at so-called liberal MFA and PhD
creative writing programs and literary journals white
professors and editors are careful not to allow whites
to be painted as the sole antagonist in African poetry
and fiction, which makes it even more interesting that Stockett does not list Richard Wright ,
Margaret Walker
Alexander
Alexander, and
Ellen Douglas as noteworthy
Mississippians in her postlude, there is no denying that Stockett has crafted a well-told story that receives its
tension from the layering of characterization and the
conflict that Stockett battled as she wrote it:
|
The Help is fiction, by and large.
Still, as I wrote it, I wondered an awful lot what my
family would think of it, and what Demetrie [the maid
who helped raise her] would have thought too, even
though she was long dead. I was scared, a lot of the
time, that I was crossing a terrible line, writing in
the voice of a black person. I was afraid I would fail
to describe a relationship that was so intensely
influential in my life, so loving, so grossly
stereotyped in American history…Like my feelings for
Mississippi, my feelings for
The Help conflict greatly…I
am afraid I have told too much…I am afraid I have told
too little…What I am sure about is this: I don’t
presume to think that I know what it really felt like to
be a black woman in Mississippi, especially in the
1960s. I don’t think it is something any white woman on
the other end of a black woman’s paycheck could ever
truly understand. But trying to understand is vital to
our humanity (450-451). |
To be clear, I am a Black
Nationalist who thinks that
Jackie Robinson breaking the
color barrier in professional baseball only served to
limit greatly the number of black-owned businesses as
integration has merely meant the perpetuation of African
second-class citizenship. And for those quick to
identify the election of President Obama as a great
achievement of American integration I assert that he was
only elected because Bush II drove the American Titanic
into the economic iceberg and that the emergence of the
Tea Party has the same historical significance of the
emergence of the Klan after the
Hayes-Tilden
Compromise.
However, the value in Stockett’s writing is
that she does not settle for the falsity of “Can’t we
all just get along?” but seeks to present difficult
questions about the struggle of personal and communal
concerns, showing that we all must make difficult
decisions of how best to navigate those waters to
achieve what is best for oneself, one’s race, and others
who seem different than us. Though not nearly as dense,
Stockett uses the historical novel in much the same way
as Walker uses
Jubilee—to forecast, make commentary, and
raise timely questions that the readers will be forced
to ignore or answer. But, even if those questions are
ignored, Stockett has fulfilled her artistic
responsibility of painting a work that raises these
uncomfortable questions.
Works Cited
Du Bois, W. E. B. “The Criteria of
Negro Art.”
The Norton Anthology of African American
Literature. Ed. Henry Louis Gates. New York: W. W.
Norton & Company, 1997.
Hughes, Langston. “The
Negro Artist and the Racial Mountain.”
The Norton Anthology of African American
Literature. Ed. Henry Louis
Gates. New York: W. W. Norton & Company, 1997.
Stockett, Kathryn.
The Help. New
York: Amy Einhorn Books, 2009.
posted 26 May 2011
*
* * * *
|
C.
Liegh McInnis is an instructor of
English at Jackson State University, the
publisher and editor of Black Magnolias
Literary Journal, and the author of seven
books, including four collections of poetry,
one collection of short fiction (Scripts:
Sketches and Tales of Urban Mississippi),
and one work of literary criticism (The
Lyrics of Prince: A Literary Look at a
Creative, Musical Poet, Philosopher, and
Storyteller). He has presented papers
at national conferences, such as College
Language Association and the Neo-Griot
Conference, and his work has appeared in
Bum Rush the Page: A Def Poetry Jam,
Sable, New Delta Review, The
Black World Today, In Motion Magazine,
MultiCultural Review, A Deeper
Shade, New Laurel Review,
ChickenBones, and the Oxford American.
|
In January of 2009,
C. Liegh, along with eight other poets, was invited to
read poetry in Washington, DC by the NAACP for their
Inaugural Poetry Reading celebrating the election of
President Barack Obama. He has also been invited by
colleges and libraries all over the country to read his
poetry and fiction and to lecture on various topics,
such creative writing and various aspects of African
American literature, music, and history.
McInnis is editor of
Black Magnolias Literary Journal.—PsychedelicLiterature
*
* * * *
|
Black Magnolias Literary Journal is
a quarterly that uses poetry, fiction, and
prose to examine and celebrate the social,
political, and aesthetic accomplishments of
African Americans with an emphasis on
Afro-Mississippians and Afro-Southerners.
We
welcome pieces on a variety of African
American and Afro-Southern culture,
including history, politics, education,
incidents/events, social life, and
literature. All submissions are to be made
by e-mail as a word attachment to
psychedeliclit@bellsouth.net . Each
issue costs $12.00, and a year’s
subscription is $40.00. |
 |
* *
* * *
Kathryn
Stockett Is Not My Sister and I Am Not Her Help—Duchess
Harris, Ph.D., J.D.—I did not attend
Wednesday’s movie release of
The Help from DreamWorks Pictures, based on the
New York Times best-selling novel by
Kathryn Stockett. Why, you ask? Because I read the
book.
Last week New
York Times op-ed columnist
Frank Bruni saw an advance screening of the
movie and referred to it as “…a story of female
grit and solidarity—of strength through sisterhood.”
He wrote, “The book’s author,
Kathryn Stockett, told me that she felt that most
civil rights literature had taken a male
perspective, leaving ‘territory that hadn’t been
covered much.’” What neither Bruni nor Stockett
acknowledge is that the real territory remaining
uncovered is civil rights literature written by the
Black women who experienced it.
I recently read
The Help
with an open mind, despite some of the criticism it
has received. I assumed the book would be racially
problematic, because for me, most things are. The
novel opens on the fourth Wednesday in August 1962,
at the bridge club meeting in the modest home of
23-year old, social climbing Miss Leefolt. The plot
unfolds when her “friend” and the novel’s
antagonist, Miss Hilly, the President of the
Jackson, Mississippi Junior League, announces that
she will support legislation for a “Home Help
Sanitation Initiative,” a bill that requires every
white home to have a separate bathroom for the
colored help. (10)
We learn early
on that Miss Skeeter, the only bridge club lady with
a college degree and no husband, opposes the idea.
By page 12, she asks Miss Leefolt’s maid Aibleen,
“Do you ever wish you could…change things?” This
lays the groundwork for a 530-page novel telling the
story of Black female domestics in Jackson.
The first two
chapters were written in the voice of a Black maid
named Aibileen, so I hoped that the book would
actually be about her. But this is America, and any
Southern narrative that actually touches on race
must focus on a noble white protagonist to get us
through such dangerous territory (in this case, Miss
Skeeter; in
To Kill a Mockingbird, Atticus Finch). As a
Black female reader, I ended up feeling like one of
“the help,” forced to tend to Miss Skeeter’s
emotional sadness over the loss of her maid (whom
she loved more than her own white momma) and her
social trials regarding a clearly racist “Jim Crow”
bill.
|
What is most concerning about the text
is the empathy that we are supposed to
have for Miss Skeeter. This character
is not a true white civil rights
activist like the historical figure,
Viola Liuzzo (April 11, 1925 – March
25, 1965), a mother of five from
Michigan murdered by Ku Klux Klan
members after the 1965 Selma to
Montgomery march in Alabama. Instead,
Skeeter is a lonely recent grad of Ole
Miss, who returns home after college,
devastated that her maid is gone and
that she is “stuck” with her parents.
She remarks, “I had to accept that
Constantine, my one true ally, had left
me to fend for myself with these
people.” (81) Constantine is Miss
Skeeter’s Black maid, and it’s pretty
transparent that Stockett is writing
about herself. We learn this in the
novel’s epilogue, “Too Little, Too Late:
Kathryn Stockett,
in her own words.”
“My
parents divorced when I was six.
Demetrie became even more important
then. When my mother went on one of her
frequent trips[…] I’d cry and cry on
Demetrie’s shoulder, missing my mother
so bad I’d get a fever from it.” (p.
527)
photo right:
Duchess Harris, Ph.D.,
J.D. |
 |
“I’m pretty
sure I can say that no one in my family ever asked
Demetrie what it felt like to be black in
Mississippi, working for our white family. It never
occurred to us to ask. It was everyday life. It
wasn’t something people felt compelled to examine.
I have wished, for many years, that I’d been old
enough and thoughtful enough to ask Demetrie the
same question. She died when I was sixteen. I’ve
spent years imagining what her answer would be. And
that is why I wrote this book.” (p. 530)
It would have
behooved Stockett to ask her burning question of
another Black domestic, or at least read some
memoirs on the subject, but instead she substitutes
her imagination for understanding. And the result
is that
The Help
isn’t for Black women at all, and quickly devolves
into just another novel by and for white women.
But when the
novel attempts to enter the mindset of the Black
women, like Aibleen or her best friend Minny,
suddenly we enter the realm of the ridiculous.
Although Stockett’s writing shows her talent, her
ignorance of the real lives of the Black women
bleeds through. Her Black characters lack the
credibility reflected in
Coming of Age in Mississippi,
a 1968 memoir by
Anne Moody, an African American woman growing up
in rural Mississippi in the 1960s. Moody recalls
doing domestic work for white families from the age
of nine. Moody’s voice is one of a real Black woman
who left her own house and family each morning to
cook in another woman’s kitchens.
So instead of
incorporating a real Black woman’s voice in a novel
purported to being about Black domestics, the
Skeeter/Stockett character is comfortingly
centralized, and I can see why white women relate to
her. She is depicted as a budding feminist, who is
enlightened and brave. But in reality, she uses the
stories of the Black domestics in the name of
“sisterhood” to launch her own career, and then
leaves them behind. In my experience, the Skeeters
of the world grow up to be Gloria Steinem.
In a certain
sense,
The Help
exemplifies the disconnect many Black women have
felt from Feminist Movement through the second
wave. For 20 years, I read accounts of Black women
who were alienated from that movement primarily
populated by middle-class white women. Black women
have asserted their voices since the 1960s as a
means of revising feminism and identifying the gap
previously denied by the movement and filled by
their minds, spirits and bodies. Yet, because I was
born in the midst of the second wave and the Black
Feminist Movement, I never felt alienated, myself,
until the 2008 Presidential election.
It started with
the extremely unpleasant showdown between
Gloria Steinem and
Melissa Harris-Lacewell, (now
Perry) surrounding Steinem’s New York Times
op-ed about then-Senator Barack Obama. This was
followed by the late
Geraldine Ferraro’s
dismissive comments that Senator Obama was
winning the race because he was not White. “If Obama
was a white man, he would not be in this position. …
He happens to be very lucky to be who he is. And the
country is caught up in the concept.”—FeministWire
* *
* * *
Black Maid
Sues Says
The Help
Is Humiliating— By Susan Donaldson James—22
February 2011—A lawsuit against
Kathryn Stockett, the author of best-selling
novel
The Help
has divided brother and sister in a dispute about
the real-life identity of one of her fictional
characters. Ablene Cooper, the longtime nanny for
Stockett's brother, has filed a $75,000 lawsuit
against the author, claiming she was upset by the
book that characterizes black maids working for
white families in the family's hometown of Jackson,
Miss., during the 1960s.
Cooper also
once babysat for Stockett's daughter, according to
the
Jackson Clarion Ledger, and the lawsuit alleges
that she had been assured by Stockett, 42, that her
likeness would not be used in the book.The 2009
novel was an instant favorite among book clubs,
written in the voice of black "help" by a woman
raised by maids herself and who is white.Cooper, 60,
maintains that the book's fictional character—Aibileen
Clark—is her. She says the alleged unauthorized
appropriation of her name and image is emotionally
upsetting, and her employers, Carol and Robert
Stockett III agree. He is Kathryn Stockett's brother
and employs Cooper as a nanny and maid.— ABCnews
* * *
* *
* *
* * *
 |
The Help
By
Kathryn
Stockett
Four peerless actors render an array of
sharply defined black and white
characters in the nascent years of the
civil rights movement. They each handle
a variety of Southern accents with
aplomb and draw out the daily
humiliation and pain the maids are
subject to, as well as their abiding
affection for their white charges. The
actors handle the narration and dialogue
so well that no character is ever
stereotyped, the humor is always
delightful, and the listener is led
through the multilayered stories of
maids and mistresses. The novel is a
superb intertwining of personal and
political history in Jackson, Miss., in
the early 1960s, but this reading gives
it a deeper and fuller power.—Publishers
Weekly
In
writing about such a troubled time in
American history, Southern-born Stockett
takes a big risk, one that paid off
enormously. Critics praised Stockett's
skillful depiction of the ironies and
hypocrisies that defined an era, without
resorting to depressing or controversial
clichés. Rather, Stockett focuses on the
fascinating and complex relationships
between vastly different members of a
household. Additionally, reviewers loved
(and loathed) Stockett's
three-dimensional characters—and cheered
and hissed their favorites to the end.
Several critics questioned Stockett's
decision to use a heavy dialect solely
for the black characters. Overall,
however, The Help is a
compassionate, original story, as well
as an excellent choice for book groups.—Bookmarks
Magazine |
* *
* * *
|
Living In, Living Out
African American Domestics in
Washington, D.C., 1910-1940
By Elizabeth Clark-Lewis
This vivid tale of social transformation
is original; the interview material is
stunning. No one else has the richness
of data about women making the
transition from rural to urban,
agricultural to industrial, southern to
northern, family-dominated to
individual-directed life. This is an
extraordinarily rich account of a group
of women in the very process of making
these shifts basic to the creation of
our urban, individualistic world. That
they are African American women
domestics makes the story even more
striking and delicious.—Phyllis Palmer, author of Domesticity and Dirt
With candor and passion, the women
interviewed tell of leaving their
families and adjusting to city life “up
North,” of being placed as live-in
servants, and of the frustrations and
indignities they endured as domestics.
By networking on the job, at churches,
and at penny savers clubs, they found
ways to transform their unending
servitude into an employer-employee
relationship—gaining a new independence
that could only be experienced by living
outside of their employers' homes.
Clark-Lewis points out that their
perseverance and courage not only
improved their own lot but also
transformed work life for succeeding
generations of African American women. A
series of in-depth vignettes about the
later years of these women bears
poignant witness to their efforts to
carve out lives of fulfilment and
dignity.—Smithsonian
Books |
 |
* *
* * *
 |
To 'Joy
My Freedom
Southern Black Women's Lives and Labors
after the Civil War
By Tera W. Hunter With great
breadth, sensitivity, and intellectual integrity, Tera Hunter
reorients southern history toward the
urban working class. This tour de force
further liberates African-American
history from the need always to relate
to whites. Bravo!—Nell Irvin Painter, Princeton
University By bringing to
life the experiences, aspirations, and struggles of the black
domestic workers of Atlanta, Tera Hunter opens a new window on the
study of emancipation and its aftermath
and, in so doing, tremendously enriches
our understanding of Reconstruction and
the New South.—Eric Foner, Columbia
University In
To 'Joy
My Freedom, Tera W. Hunter charts the efforts of African-American
women in Atlanta to live fulfilling
lives despite an all-pervasive racism,
which was most terrifying in the city's
infamous race riot of 1906...One can
only applaud Hunter's efforts to recover
the experience of her subjects from
obscurity.—Times Literary Supplement |
* *
* * *
The White Masters of the
World
From
The World and Africa, 1965
By W. E. B. Du Bois
W. E. B. Du Bois’
Arraignment and Indictment of White Civilization
(Fletcher)
* *
* * *
Ancient African Nations
* * * * *
If you like this page consider making a donation
* * * * *
Negro Digest /
Black World
Browse all issues
1950
1960
1965
1970
1975
1980
1985
1990
1995
2000
____ 2005
Enjoy!
* * * * *
The Death of Emmett Till by Bob Dylan
/
The Lonesome Death of Hattie Carroll
/
Only a Pawn in Their Game
Rev. Jesse Lee Peterson Thanks America for
Slavery
* *
* * *
The Journal of Negro History issues at Project Gutenberg
The
Haitian Declaration of Independence 1804
/
January 1, 1804 -- The Founding of
Haiti
* * * * *
* *
* * *
ChickenBones Store
(Books, DVDs, Music, and more)
updated 7 February 2012
|